Monday, May 02, 2011

Some Final Election 2011 Thoughts

Tonight, the 41st election in Canada's history will reshape our political map.

Or not.

Depending on factors that are beyond the ability of mere mortals to predict, we will either get a slim Conservative majority or the wildest, craziest election result the country has ever seen.

A quick recap:

- The "Seinfeld election" the Tories desperately wanted us to have died with the debates. Pundits will look back on this campaign and see that Layton landed punches in those events that resonated far beyond what was considered his base support. Everything changed from that point on, and the Liberals and Tories were slow to react. We'll see if they reacted well enough to dampen Dipper dreams.

- The Conservatives have campaigned on a "majority or bust" basis. For Stephen Harper, anything less than a majority is a loss. I think it's highly unlikely he keeps his job if the Tories are held to a minority. However, if he wins a majority, he gains the chance to solidify his gains over the next four years. I view this moment as a razor's edge point in our country's evolution. I hope voters pull us back from the brink.

- The Liberals under Michael Ignatieff are sliding further and further into irrelevance. While people have been talking incessantly about the NDP "orange crush" that started in Quebec and started affecting voting intentions elsewhere, less ink has been spilled about the fact the Grits have launched a similar red tide across the country. Starting with the sponsorship scandal, the Liberal Party has failed to reverse a spreading sentiment of discontent and disinterest in their policies and personnel. As much as the Dipper Wave is the main story of the past two weeks, the Descent Into The Red for Ignatieff's party (which is now taking hold across the country and was first triggered in Quebec) is a story for the historical ages.

- Gilles Duceppe has fought his last election campaign. The destruction of Election 2011 leaves him with no option but to resign, which will also kill any remnant hopes he may have had about eventually contesting the provincial PQ leadership. In the postmortem analysis of the BQ's electoral humiliation, the blame for this debacle will land squarely on his shoulders, no matter how many seats the party wins later tonight. The party itself no longer has a firm raison d'être nor a compelling case to make about its future relevance. Going forward, the Tories will absorb right-leaning voters, the NDP left-leaners, and the Liberals ... well, they'll have time to contemplate another butt-whupping dans la belle province. The BQ may remain, but only as a rump, unless they can find a purpose, and fast.

- Finally, the NDP gained the most of any party from a simmering discontent with politics as usual, the political mobilization of the youth vote, negative campaigning tactics that turned off many voters and a disintegration of the entente between soft nationalists and the sovereigntist Bloc. Whether this stunning turn of events translates into enough seats for Jack Layton to become Opposition Leader, or better, depends on fluid factors even Nostradamus would have trouble handicapping. All previous political assumptions are out the window. What lies ahead for all of us depends greatly on this party's final seat tally vis-à-vis the Conservatives.

Full disclosure: I have been fairly clear in my commentary during the campaign that I am anti-Harper and ambivalent towards Michael Ignatieff. I have always admired Jack Layton, and I campaigned on behalf of Alexa McDonough in Halifax during the 2005-06 campaign. I am not a card-carrying member of the NDP, though at points in my life I have carried a card both for that party and for the Liberals (when I was a university student at Queen's). My dislike of Ignatieff's party stems from my experience as a Young Liberal in the mid-1990s, when the pro-Martin forces were taking over the internal operations of the party in anticipation of their guy usurping Jean Chrétien in the PM's chair. I was disgusted by their methods and remain a conscientious objector to the way they do politics. I nevertheless campaigned for Peter Milliken, the former Speaker of the House of Commons, in his Kingston and the Islands riding during the 1997 and 2000 election campaigns. I have a great deal of respect for Peter, whom I consider a friend, and wish him all the best in his retirement.

I am not a disinterested commentator. I am not an NDP shill, but I also hew closest to their political philosophy and ideas. I believe all Canadians should express their personal political views as clearly and as loudly as they feel comfortable doing, and I certainly have chosen this blog to do that very thing. However, I believe strongly that all people should exercise their franchise in the way they believe is best.

I implore you to go to the polls and vote your conscience (whether that's in accordance with your personal views or a strategic ballot) before the ballot boxes are sealed today. Vote for whichever party you support, and be proud to register your opinion this way. And if you feel none of the above should get your vote, then go to your polling station and spoil your ballot. Don't take your rights for granted. Stand up and be counted.

Then go home to relax with family and friends, and take in the coverage that will be all over the airwaves tonight. May 2, 2011 will be a historic day. Participate in it.

Saturday, April 30, 2011

As I Glance Into My Crystal Ball ...

There are so many possible outcomes from Monday's election that the mind boggles. Conservative majority, Tory minority, NDP/Liberal coalition, NDP minority, Conservative/Liberal coalition, Liberal/NDP coalition, Liberal minority ... all these exist as possible governing options for the country.

Despite this reality, there are only two results actually possible on May 2, to my mind: a Tory majority or a Tory minority; however, there are several different ways the second situation might play itself out. Let's do a quick overview:

1. Conservative Majority

Stephen Harper's strategy of micro-campaigning is aided by the NDP surge in the final week of the campaign. Vote splits in Quebec City, southern Ontario, pockets of the Atlantic and in B.C. nearly all break his way, and the Tories eke out a majority victory. Harper's ultimate ambition is realized. Such a result is possible only if the Liberals lose a bunch of seats and the NDP is strong enough in Quebec to drop the Bloc back a few MPs as well. It matters little whether the Liberals, NDP or Bloc form the Official Opposition in this instance. This result leaves Canada with a conservative hue to its government that nearly two-thirds of it didn't want, and no way to change the situation for four years. 

In terms of democracy, accountability and the desires of the Canadian people, this is the singular worst outcome -- a nightmare scenario for anyone who thinks Harper needs to be called on the carpet for previous behaviour. 

2. Conservative Minority

Based on current polling trends, this seems to be the most likely outcome (though nothing is truly as it seems in this campaign). Under this scenario, the Conservatives will win anywhere between 135-154 seats on Monday. This is short of a majority but also a clear first-place finish. Such a scenario means the voting splits mentioned above didn't all break the Tories' way, meaning many or all of the following: NDP gains in Quebec and BC, a mix of Liberal holds and NDP pick-ups in Ontario, and a bit of seat-shifting in the Atlantic unfavourable to Harper's party.

The scenario is highly fluid, of course, but in all likelihood this result would mean the NDP has made significant increases in its seat total. As the Liberal vote collapsed in the past week, people moved in numbers to support the NDP. If this trend holds out on Election Day, Layton would become the Leader of the Opposition. It's tough to see a scenario where Michael Ignatieff retains the role, unless the masses of Quebeckers suddenly decided to go back to the Bloc -- an event I see as highly improbable. But it is possible. More on that later.

In a hung Parliament where no party commands a majority, the Tories would retain government and have the first opportunity to try to gain the confidence of the House of Commons. At that point, here's what could happen:

(a) The Tories are permitted to govern 

I wrote about this in a previous blog post, before the NDP surge changed the calculus somewhat. This can still happen, and in fact I think is the most likely outcome with an NDP Opposition. 

If Jack Layton leads the second party in the House, the Liberals wouldn't be keen to join with the NDP to govern, either on a case-by-case basis, in a negotiated arrangement or in a coalition. It would be like signing their own death warrant; such a move could be seen as a Grit invitation to the NDP to permanently replace them as the main alternative to the Tories. In all probability, the number of MPs in the Liberal and Tory caucuses would constitute a working majority. The Tories would amend their budgetary proposals and consult with the Grits to create a government agenda Ignatieff and the rest of his chastened crew could live with, thereby ensuring the NDP could not make a play for power. 

The price of Tory compromise for the Liberals, however, would be exclusion from Cabinet. I believe the Tories would either seek to govern ad hoc (which I think the Liberals would reject out of hand), or offer to make the Throne Speech the blueprint of a joint Tory/Grit agenda, similar to the 1985-87 Ontario Liberal/NDP accord that brought David Peterson to power in Toronto, propped up by Bob Rae. Tories would do this, even if it gives the Liberals a bit of a lease on new life, in order to prevent the NDP from making their own arrangements to toss Harper out of power. 

Where it becomes interesting is if either party demands the other partner dump their leader as part of the deal. Liberals would want assurances Harper would not be retained as Prime Minister, while the Tories may not want to sign an accord with the "just visiting" Ignatieff still at the Liberal helm.

I should also mention that the Bloc would probably also be able to combine their parliamentary votes with the Tories to keep them in power; however, given Gilles Duceppe's ongoing vilification by Harper as a traitor to Canada and Duceppe's bald disdain for Harper's autocratic tendencies, I see this as unlikely indeed.

(b) The Tories are brought down and the NDP is in position to govern

If the Tories refuse to compromise or cannot come to an agreement with the Liberals (or the Bloc) to remain in power, their government will fall as soon as Parliament convenes, likely on a confidence vote on their Throne Speech. Harper would then have to visit Governor General David Johnston at Rideau Hall and tender his resignation as Prime Minister. I believe he would also request new elections. This is where things get interesting.

It's doubtful the GG will simply hand the keys to 24 Sussex to Layton. Knowing there is no appetite for a new election, Johnston would seek to avoid one; however, he will want to know Layton can command the confidence of the House. If Layton were able to work out an agreement with the Liberals (in this case, I think a coalition in which the Grits hold some of the economic portfolios is the only way such a deal gets done), then the NDP could be offered the opportunity to do the unprecedented -- govern in Canada at the federal level.

(c) The Tories are brought down and the Liberals are in position to govern

Some Liberals insist the impending demise of the Liberal Party of Canada has been greatly exaggerated, and the multitude of Liberal voters who stayed home in 2008 will come out and come through for their party. I personally don't believe it, but I also didn't think Jack Layton could become Opposition Leader two weeks ago, either. So I don't discount it out of hand, as some other commentators have done.

If the Liberals are able to hold together and get enough of their supporters out to the ballot boxes on Monday, they could still finish ahead of the NDP in seat count (though they cannot catch the Tories in this respect) through favourable vote splits in parts of the Atlantic, the Montreal area, southern and eastern Ontario, and the Lower Mainland in B.C. The Bloc would also have to hold many of its most contested seats in Quebec to keep the NDP seat count lower that the Grits'. Should Ignatieff remain the Leader of the Opposition, defeating the Tories on their Throne Speech is pretty much the only way he can keep his job as head of the party.

Should the Tories fall under this scenario, the call from the GG would be placed to Ignatieff, and not to Layton. He would probably have to present evidence of NDP and Bloc willingness to permit him to govern, through either gaining a deal on a budget, through a longer-term accord, or through a coalition with the NDP. If Ignatieff were to approach Layton for support under these conditions, I don't see any way the Liberals avoid putting Dippers in Cabinet. The biggest knock against the NDP is their lack of governmental experience. You can bet they want to change that before the next time voters are asked to pass judgement on the members of the House of Commons.

(d) None of the above

However, if it all fell apart and a new election became the only option left, voters would blame the whole lot of them. The writs would be dropped, the politicians would hit the hustings again -- and all bets would be off.

Friday, April 29, 2011

And Just to Reiterate ...

I was chatting with a friend of mine this afternoon, and the subject of Bob Rae's NDP premiership came up in our election talk. I asked her: how old were you when Bob Rae was elected Ontario premier in October 1990? She said she was four years old.

This woman is a tireless NDP campaign worker. She represents a cohort of young people energized by Jack Layton and working to have him and other members of his team elected on Monday. They have no memory of the Rae years, and frankly don't care. It holds no relevance to Jack, to the federal scene, or to the NDP's ability to bring forward its message in the current context, a full two decades after Ontarians took a chance on the province's traditional third party.

Stephen Harper, Michael Ignatieff, plus all the pundits and political commentators who are trying to create fear and trepidation about the spectre of a strengthened NDP in Ottawa miss this crucial point. If voters under 35 turn out in big numbers, the people who expect an NDP pullback similar to 1988 will be in for a shock.

I don't think it'll happen. The support levels we're seeing in these final days of polling will hold true on voting day. I expect to see the NDP numbers in the 28-33% range when it's all said and done. That will be more than enough to hold the Conservatives to a minority, and to garner the NDP between 60-80 seats.

A fierce repudiation of the Liberals and the Bloc is in process, and will be locked in on Monday. The Tories will not get their coveted majority. 

And Jack Layton will be the only federal leader still in his job by this time next year.

When Life (or the Liberal Party) Hands You Oranges ...

Michael Ignatieff is feeling the squeeze.

Here's a man who knows his history, so let me put this in a way he can understand: the Germans learned in the world wars how difficult it can be to fight a war on two fronts. Eventually, the forces on either side of you get their machines working at full capacity, and your stretched resources cannot effectively put up a resistance on both flanks simultaneously.

This looks like the election when the left finally coalesces around an actual left-leaning national party. This phenomenon already took place on the right a decade ago, when the Reform/Alliance and Progressive Conservative forces made nice and united under Stephen Harper. With the reorientation of the progressive vote in Quebec spurring an Orange Crush now sweeping the nation towards a radical re-shifting of the political landscape, the Liberals look shell-shocked.

It didn't have to be this way. When Harper became leader of the Conservative Party, it was clear to me that any attempt to keep them out of power would require a leftist reaction from the Liberals. After Paul Martin lost the January 2006 election, the Grits were presented an opportunity to do just that. Bob Rae, the former NDP premier of Ontario, was seeking the leadership in a field that included Ken Dryden, Stephane Dion, Scott Brison, Ignatieff and others. He was clearly the way to go if a truly centre-left orientation was to take hold of the party. Ignatieff, though popular in some circles, did not have the internal support to win the leadership at a convention where his growth potential was viewed as very weak. Dion, though left-leaning himself, was not seen as a credible alternative by those who valued beating Harper above all else.

Well, you know what happened -- egos got in the way. Ignatieff couldn't admit he could not win and refused to do the sensible thing (throw his support behind Rae) because he was determined to humble his old university buddy. Rae fell off the ballot and Ignatieff got served by Dion.

In my mind, that is the root of what we are seeing today. At some point, disaffected left-leaning voters were always going to need somewhere to go that could push the Conservatives out of power. The Liberals were stuck in purgatory after the sponsorship scandal, and Harper was busy sucking up all the centre-right air in a bid to make his fledging party more palatable to the electorate. So the Liberals did the stupidest thing possible: pretended to be left-leaning while eventually moving to pursue a centre-right agenda.

This worked in the past, but people, the 20th century is so over.

The Liberals tanked under Dion, as predicted, and the party began the process of turfing him almost immediately after the debacle that was the 2008 election was over. But not soon enough to avoid the Coalition Crisis that very nearly saw him become Prime Minister. The Liberal brand took another hit.

The diversionary Dion experiment was time that could have been better spent re-establishing Rae's leadership credentials if Liberals had chosen him instead. I'm not going to pronounce judgement on Rae as a politician here; it's not the focus of my thoughts in this context. I'm simply pointing out that Rae could have provided the one thing the Liberals have lacked since 2004 -- credible clash with the Conservatives.

Dion clashed, that's for sure, but he clashed with everyone -- the Tories, the other opposition parties, the Liberal leadership, the electorate. But by comparison, Rae represented a brighter opportunity to stake out new ground in contrast to the Conservatives and a firmer foundation from which to rebuild the party internally. A Liberal party that chose to try and squeeze out a bigger space for itself on the centre-left would have been more successful with a guy who had more gravitas, statesmanlike credentials and campaigning experience than they ever were with Dion.

The party then chose Ignatieff as leader in May 2009 and squeezed Rae out again, this time without even bothering to have a true leadership contest. Rae was outmanouvred that time by a guy who didn't leave anything to chance while Dion was busy blowing his shot. The new leader immediately tried to force an election, failed, and the Liberal downward spiral continued.

Which leads us to the present moment. Ignatieff has always been hawkish on foreign affairs and defense issues. In many ways he is indistinguishable from Harper from a policy perspective. From 2004 to 2011, the progression of the Liberal leadership has been to try and take on the Tories on their turf. In the midst of all that, they have tried to tell progressives that their votes are necessary to stop Harper from gaining a majority of House seats, and so they should hold their noses and vote Liberal.

I always felt this was wrong-headed. For them to govern, I believe they should have staked out ground a little further left than that with a leader who is not a Harper clone or as flawed as Dion, then appeal to centrists who used to vote Progressive Conservative and ask them to return Canada to a state they could recognize. In that way, the 20-25% of Canadians that form Harper's hard-core base could never again get close to power. There are more votes in this configuration, and more potential avenues to power. I could never figure out how the Liberals couldn't see that.

Instead, they allowed whatever limited progressive credibility they had after Chretien left office be frittered away through the combination of ineptitude, infighting, awful election campaigns in 2005-06 and 2008, and parliamentary miscalculations and missteps. Now in this campaign, their leader is not viewed as truly progressive and their performance as a party during the campaign has been, to put it mildly, underwhelming. By taking on Harper following his rules, they were bound to lose from the start.

That's one of the main reasons the NDP is surging now. Jack Layton has remained consistent for years on what he wants to do, he has never wavered from his commitment to work with other parties in Parliament no matter what the electorate says, and he is the most credible progressive voice on the federal scene. His message has been more positive than the other parties, and more directly aimed at the wide swatch of lower and middle class voters concerned about Tory policies. For years he has been putting in work to create new avenues of support for the party, and has remained doggedly focused on becoming Prime Minister, an objective greeted with snorts of derision from most people until about 10 days ago. Now that the Green Party and Bloc vote have swung to him, and the polls are showing he's the only leader with momentum in the final days of a suddenly-fascinating campaign, the errors of past years have come home to roost for the Liberals.

The electorate is no longer chicken when it comes to voting NDP. The trends are firming up, and the NDP continues to grow in support, even in polls released today. There will be a big shift in voting patterns come Monday. It's no longer a question of if Layton will make big gains, but rather a question of how big.

I'm sure Bob Rae as leader of the Liberal Party during this time of radical rethinking of progressive electoral strategy would have made the Grits more competitive than the increasingly desperate and shrill Michael Ignatieff.

I believe we are witnessing the end as we know it of the most successful political party in the democratic world. The Liberal Party of Canada will live on after May 2 -- this is a prognosis, not an obituary. But if current polling numbers hold true to election day (and I believe they will), it may be a very long time before we see it rise to challenge for a majority government again.

Thank you, Liberals. Orange juice is my favorite drink anyway. I'll be sipping it liberally on Monday night.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

The Mercer Effect

"If you look at these numbers, that would represent potentially a pretty interesting shift in the balance of power, certainly on the opposition benches. That balance of power is kind of in the hands of the youth vote right now."
- Jaideep Mukerji, vice-president of Angus Reid Public Opinion, commenting yesterday on April 26 polling results

Rick Mercer's now-famous rant challenging young people aged 18 to 24 to vote has had a shocking effect on this campaign. To the surprise of many, youth have mobilized through creating new groups focused on getting out the youth vote, utilizing social media and other means to push their message, and through the vote mob phenomenon sweeping across Canada's university campuses. Despite condescending criticism from "wise elders" who dismiss it all as just so much noise, the focused sharpness of the retorts to such talk, plus the massive shifts in recent polls, indicate Canada's youth are finally seeking to be heard en masse through increased political engagement.

We must wait until the votes are counted to see how many youth actually turn out to cast ballots, but the early indications are that the Conservatives should be concerned. Last year, fewer than 1 in 5 youth expressed support for Harper, and there's little reason to believe that's changed very much. So any significant increase in youth voter turnout is not going to fall into their column. However, it's tough to say how that will influence vote splits in competitive ridings given how unpredictable the campaign has become in last week.

One thing is certain, though -- something is afoot in the electorate, and unpredictable things will almost assuredly happen. Will Jack Layton become Leader of the Opposition? Will Stephen Harper succeed in winning a majority with a reduced percentage of the national vote from 2008? Will Michael Ignatieff still be the Liberal leader by Canada Day? Will Gilles Duceppe still be the Bloc leader by Victoria Day? And just how many young people will vote next Monday anyway?

Right now, as Mukerji posited yesterday, a sizeable factor in how the vote turns out is in the hands of Canada's youth. If they seize it, our politics will be forever altered.

Source:
http://anomalism.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d1ps0d
“It’s conventional wisdom of all political parties that young people will not vote. And the parties, they like it that way … so please, if you are between 18 and 25 and you want to scare the heck out of the people who run this country, this time around, do the unexpected. Take twenty minutes out of your day and do what young people all over the world are dying to do: vote.”
- Rick Mercer