A place for personal reflection and political/social commentary from Greg "Ritallin" Frankson, a poet/writer based in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Friday, May 06, 2011
Change to the Look of PS&R
I decided the site was in need of a refresh, so I flipped up the design and changed a few small aspects of the layout. I hope you like the new look!
Thursday, May 05, 2011
Barbarism and Sacrifice
Two significant news stories today that, at first, seem related in only a peripheral way, have come together in my thinking. The first is U.S. President Barack Obama's decisions not to release photos of Osama bin Laden's corpse, and to travel to New York today to lay a wreath at the site of the destroyed World Trade Centre. The second is the death of the last surviving veteran of World War I in Australia.
In a world of raging armed conflicts, devastating natural disasters, horrendous social and political upheavals, oppressive dictatorships and epidemic disease, it's amazing to me how much we can concentrate on whether or not we are entitled to see a blasted hulk of human flesh captured on a digital camera. Whether you believe the Americans or think they are lying (a discussion I don't want to get into), I find it reprehensible that people are actually celebrating murder like it's their daughter's fifth birthday party and she just opened all her presents. I find the lack of respect for the death of another human being to be galling.
And yes, the person in this case is bin Laden. I get that he's the world's most wanted man, a terrorist who inspired and supported the mass murder of thousands of people on U.S. soil in September 2001. He's not Mother Teresa. I'm not a fool, I know he's not a sympathetic figure. But what does it say when we can't even restrain ourselves enough to be more muted in response to news of his assassination?
Are we barbarians?
By comparison, the death of Claude Stanley Choules is receiving very little fanfare. He was the last known living combatant from the Great War, a conflict that was our first experience with total war. People like to say that our soldiers who fought in the trenches along the Western Front, and the ones who sacrificed so much to fight in the Second World War as well, did so in defense of our rights and freedoms. They were noble warriors, sent to do a dirty job that needed doing, and we should never forget their sacrifice.
Based on what I saw in the news media over the last couple of days with respect to bin Laden's assassination, however, I think we've already forgotten. The pursuit of liberty and peace is never easy, nor always tidy, but we should never try to attain it at the cost of our humanity. Photos or no, I believe the actions of people in the West are provocation enough for those who feel we are dancing on a dead man's grave.
Our history, principles and moral code, if we truly value them, would be better protected if we were less self-congratulatory and more sober in our response to bin Laden's murder. Claude Choules and others like him didn't risk their lives so we could behave like this. We should strive to do better than to stoop to the level of common thugs while seeking a higher purpose.
In a world of raging armed conflicts, devastating natural disasters, horrendous social and political upheavals, oppressive dictatorships and epidemic disease, it's amazing to me how much we can concentrate on whether or not we are entitled to see a blasted hulk of human flesh captured on a digital camera. Whether you believe the Americans or think they are lying (a discussion I don't want to get into), I find it reprehensible that people are actually celebrating murder like it's their daughter's fifth birthday party and she just opened all her presents. I find the lack of respect for the death of another human being to be galling.
And yes, the person in this case is bin Laden. I get that he's the world's most wanted man, a terrorist who inspired and supported the mass murder of thousands of people on U.S. soil in September 2001. He's not Mother Teresa. I'm not a fool, I know he's not a sympathetic figure. But what does it say when we can't even restrain ourselves enough to be more muted in response to news of his assassination?
Are we barbarians?
By comparison, the death of Claude Stanley Choules is receiving very little fanfare. He was the last known living combatant from the Great War, a conflict that was our first experience with total war. People like to say that our soldiers who fought in the trenches along the Western Front, and the ones who sacrificed so much to fight in the Second World War as well, did so in defense of our rights and freedoms. They were noble warriors, sent to do a dirty job that needed doing, and we should never forget their sacrifice.
Based on what I saw in the news media over the last couple of days with respect to bin Laden's assassination, however, I think we've already forgotten. The pursuit of liberty and peace is never easy, nor always tidy, but we should never try to attain it at the cost of our humanity. Photos or no, I believe the actions of people in the West are provocation enough for those who feel we are dancing on a dead man's grave.
Our history, principles and moral code, if we truly value them, would be better protected if we were less self-congratulatory and more sober in our response to bin Laden's murder. Claude Choules and others like him didn't risk their lives so we could behave like this. We should strive to do better than to stoop to the level of common thugs while seeking a higher purpose.
Wednesday, May 04, 2011
Evaluate, Pontificate, Consolidate
Now that the voting is out of the way and Canadians have delivered a verdict that surprised even themselves, I see a few themes emerging in the coming days and weeks:
- The Liberal Party must go back to the drawing board and figure themselves out. Whatever they've been peddling since the retirement of Jean Chretien simply hasn't cut it, and with Michael Ignatieff's resignation, they enter yet another period of soul-searching. For their own sakes, they better actually do the hard work this time. Canadians don't feel like they owe Liberals anything. It appears as if that news was a shock to Canada's "natural governing party" but it's been that way for four elections now. It took a LONG time for the message to sink in. Perhaps being reduced to a rump presence in Parliament will finally do the trick! The lesson is clear -- if they want electoral success in the future, they're going to have to earn it.
- The Bloc Quebecois is finished. I've put forward practical reasons why a revival is unlikely, so it will now fall to the NDP to find a way to incorporate their voices into the traditional structure of their party. If there is a single organization that will have to adapt more adroitly to the new political reality than the New Democratic Party of Canada, I'd like to see it. And before you say the Liberals, consider this: the NDP beat their previous best of 43 seats in 1988 without factoring in their Quebec seats. With 44 seats in English Canada and 58 seats in Quebec, in a party that has never before elected more than one Quebec MP at a single go, working out the potential differences within the caucus will be Layton's most difficult managerial task.
- Now is not the time for the Conservatives to go rogue. For five years, Harper and his gang have run roughshod over their opponents, the rules and protocols of Parliament, and even the basic principles of democracy itself. Incredibly, and primarily due to the utter failure of the Liberals to propose anything of substance that Canadians would accept, they have been handed a majority mandate. They need to remember that even though our first-past-the-post voting system gave them a majority of seats, three-fifths of voters wanted someone else to govern. They should see this situation as both an opportunity and a very dangerous situation. If they blow it by going overboard, they will ruin their chances at governance for a generation. If they get it right, they can stay in government for a long, long time to come.
All parties need to take a few days to consider the implications of the vote on their political fortunes. Internal party officials will discuss next steps and the leaders will dole out Cabinet or critic roles as appropriate. New strategies will be created and implemented. Staff will be hired. Research will be conducted. And the Tories will craft a new Speech from the Throne to officially announce their agenda for the first parliamentary session featuring a Tory majority since Kim Campbell went to the polls in the summer of 1993.
Once the evaluation of their new situations is completed, the parties will have to spread their messages within the electorate. I believe the Tories will start to fight the next election right away. Their strategy will involve emphasizing the national nature of the party's representation as a launch pad to govern for all Canadians (or at least that's how the propaganda will go). Meanwhile, the Ontario gains and Quebec losses will become the focus, since it is only by retaining seats in the province that gave them their majority that they can rule in the long term. And part of that calculus involves dealing with Quebec well, and fairly.
They will get a bit of help in that respect from the NDP, since this will be a shared objective of the Official Opposition. As Jack Layton moves ahead, goal number one must be to get the greenhorns in his Quebec contingent up to speed and hard to work in their constituencies. The key to future success for the NDP will be how well they can serve locally and how well they can advocate in Ottawa for the province that put Layton in Stornoway. Beyond that, reconciliation of their French and English objectives will also be a critical task. Other parties in the past have imploded over such tensions, mostly on the right flank of Canadian politics (Social Credit in the 1960s and the Progressive Conservative Party in the 1990s are the two main examples). This particular accord is a completely new political arrangement in Canadian politics. How adroitly Layton navigates this potential minefield while attracting a broader following from progressives across Canada will dictate his chances of defeating Stephen Harper in 2015.
The Bloc may try to revive itself. It is tough to say exactly how they will do that, but I don't anticipate them disappearing immediately. Their most likely fate is a gradual fade into irrelevance. The only thing that can save them is an NDP failure to connect electoral success with strong representation of Quebec's interests in Ottawa. If the NDP is even at least partially successful, the future for the Bloc is bleak indeed.
The newest party to elect a representative is the Green Party of Canada. Elizabeth May invested the party's political future in winning her riding. Now that there is a majority Harper government, however, the main source of funding for her party is about to be cut off -- the per vote subsidies the Tories have vowed to end. And without a minority, her vote can never be the deciding factor in a vote, which also limits her potential impact. The key to future success for the Greens is in electoral reform, a cause that over time is increasing in popularity within the electorate; however, the real job will be to vastly increase individual donations and improve the party internally to prepare for 2015. Expanding on their electoral beachhead must be the focus for the next four years.
And finally, the Liberal Party of Canada needs to listen to Rob Silver. He and I are in agreement that the Liberals are not a left-wing party, and a merger with the NDP is nonsensical. I look forward to reading his perspectives on where he thinks the Liberals should go in the future. My thoughts are fairly straightforward: the Liberals have one chance left, only one more chance, to make themselves relevant to Canadian politics. Grit partisans need to forget about a focus on history. If they do that, they will be history. No, the path to revitalization is reinvention. Anything less than that is disaster. Liberals didn't lose in 2008 just because of Dion, they lost because the Tories have evolved with the times and changed their approaches accordingly, while the Liberals keep fighting the last war. They learned nothing from that historic debacle, and had to suffer an even greater humiliation to hopefully get the message. Another re-run of this mess and there will be nothing left.
Canada is tired of Liberal arrogance when it comes to holding power, and will never elect them again if that air of entitlement lingers a moment longer. The task is daunting, the need for leadership and determination acute. Who will lead this effort? Without the answer to this question, it's hard to see the road ahead at this stage. But that's the biggest concern for the party today. The search for the next leader should be a fascinating one.
We are in uncharted waters for all the parties. Watching it all unfold will be fascinating. But the party best able to execute their plans to achieve their most necessary goals will benefit most four years from now, when Canadians will next go to the polls to elect a government. The 41st Parliament promises to be one of the most intriguing in our history. Don't go back to sleep. Keep paying attention.
It's going to be one heck of a ride.
- The Liberal Party must go back to the drawing board and figure themselves out. Whatever they've been peddling since the retirement of Jean Chretien simply hasn't cut it, and with Michael Ignatieff's resignation, they enter yet another period of soul-searching. For their own sakes, they better actually do the hard work this time. Canadians don't feel like they owe Liberals anything. It appears as if that news was a shock to Canada's "natural governing party" but it's been that way for four elections now. It took a LONG time for the message to sink in. Perhaps being reduced to a rump presence in Parliament will finally do the trick! The lesson is clear -- if they want electoral success in the future, they're going to have to earn it.
- The Bloc Quebecois is finished. I've put forward practical reasons why a revival is unlikely, so it will now fall to the NDP to find a way to incorporate their voices into the traditional structure of their party. If there is a single organization that will have to adapt more adroitly to the new political reality than the New Democratic Party of Canada, I'd like to see it. And before you say the Liberals, consider this: the NDP beat their previous best of 43 seats in 1988 without factoring in their Quebec seats. With 44 seats in English Canada and 58 seats in Quebec, in a party that has never before elected more than one Quebec MP at a single go, working out the potential differences within the caucus will be Layton's most difficult managerial task.
- Now is not the time for the Conservatives to go rogue. For five years, Harper and his gang have run roughshod over their opponents, the rules and protocols of Parliament, and even the basic principles of democracy itself. Incredibly, and primarily due to the utter failure of the Liberals to propose anything of substance that Canadians would accept, they have been handed a majority mandate. They need to remember that even though our first-past-the-post voting system gave them a majority of seats, three-fifths of voters wanted someone else to govern. They should see this situation as both an opportunity and a very dangerous situation. If they blow it by going overboard, they will ruin their chances at governance for a generation. If they get it right, they can stay in government for a long, long time to come.
All parties need to take a few days to consider the implications of the vote on their political fortunes. Internal party officials will discuss next steps and the leaders will dole out Cabinet or critic roles as appropriate. New strategies will be created and implemented. Staff will be hired. Research will be conducted. And the Tories will craft a new Speech from the Throne to officially announce their agenda for the first parliamentary session featuring a Tory majority since Kim Campbell went to the polls in the summer of 1993.
Once the evaluation of their new situations is completed, the parties will have to spread their messages within the electorate. I believe the Tories will start to fight the next election right away. Their strategy will involve emphasizing the national nature of the party's representation as a launch pad to govern for all Canadians (or at least that's how the propaganda will go). Meanwhile, the Ontario gains and Quebec losses will become the focus, since it is only by retaining seats in the province that gave them their majority that they can rule in the long term. And part of that calculus involves dealing with Quebec well, and fairly.
They will get a bit of help in that respect from the NDP, since this will be a shared objective of the Official Opposition. As Jack Layton moves ahead, goal number one must be to get the greenhorns in his Quebec contingent up to speed and hard to work in their constituencies. The key to future success for the NDP will be how well they can serve locally and how well they can advocate in Ottawa for the province that put Layton in Stornoway. Beyond that, reconciliation of their French and English objectives will also be a critical task. Other parties in the past have imploded over such tensions, mostly on the right flank of Canadian politics (Social Credit in the 1960s and the Progressive Conservative Party in the 1990s are the two main examples). This particular accord is a completely new political arrangement in Canadian politics. How adroitly Layton navigates this potential minefield while attracting a broader following from progressives across Canada will dictate his chances of defeating Stephen Harper in 2015.
The Bloc may try to revive itself. It is tough to say exactly how they will do that, but I don't anticipate them disappearing immediately. Their most likely fate is a gradual fade into irrelevance. The only thing that can save them is an NDP failure to connect electoral success with strong representation of Quebec's interests in Ottawa. If the NDP is even at least partially successful, the future for the Bloc is bleak indeed.
The newest party to elect a representative is the Green Party of Canada. Elizabeth May invested the party's political future in winning her riding. Now that there is a majority Harper government, however, the main source of funding for her party is about to be cut off -- the per vote subsidies the Tories have vowed to end. And without a minority, her vote can never be the deciding factor in a vote, which also limits her potential impact. The key to future success for the Greens is in electoral reform, a cause that over time is increasing in popularity within the electorate; however, the real job will be to vastly increase individual donations and improve the party internally to prepare for 2015. Expanding on their electoral beachhead must be the focus for the next four years.
And finally, the Liberal Party of Canada needs to listen to Rob Silver. He and I are in agreement that the Liberals are not a left-wing party, and a merger with the NDP is nonsensical. I look forward to reading his perspectives on where he thinks the Liberals should go in the future. My thoughts are fairly straightforward: the Liberals have one chance left, only one more chance, to make themselves relevant to Canadian politics. Grit partisans need to forget about a focus on history. If they do that, they will be history. No, the path to revitalization is reinvention. Anything less than that is disaster. Liberals didn't lose in 2008 just because of Dion, they lost because the Tories have evolved with the times and changed their approaches accordingly, while the Liberals keep fighting the last war. They learned nothing from that historic debacle, and had to suffer an even greater humiliation to hopefully get the message. Another re-run of this mess and there will be nothing left.
Canada is tired of Liberal arrogance when it comes to holding power, and will never elect them again if that air of entitlement lingers a moment longer. The task is daunting, the need for leadership and determination acute. Who will lead this effort? Without the answer to this question, it's hard to see the road ahead at this stage. But that's the biggest concern for the party today. The search for the next leader should be a fascinating one.
We are in uncharted waters for all the parties. Watching it all unfold will be fascinating. But the party best able to execute their plans to achieve their most necessary goals will benefit most four years from now, when Canadians will next go to the polls to elect a government. The 41st Parliament promises to be one of the most intriguing in our history. Don't go back to sleep. Keep paying attention.
It's going to be one heck of a ride.
Tuesday, May 03, 2011
Practical Reasons Why the Bloc is Dead
The Bloc Quebecois is in its final death throes. Here's why:
1. Leadership
Bloc Leader Gilles Duceppe went down to defeat in his riding, along with nearly everyone else in his caucus. The disastrous BQ campaign can be attributed to a lack of energy, purpose and cohesion, and the person who has to take the lion's share of the blame is Duceppe. There was no way he could have remained as leader, even if he'd pulled out a win in his seat. The first Bloc MP ever elected to the House of Commons is done.
But the bigger reason why the BQ's future is so hampered by his loss is due to a lack of a clear successor. Duceppe has taken up so much of the party's oxygen over the years that there is no heir apparent to his deeply corroded crown. Plus, with the repudiation coming from all sides of their traditional support base (both nationalist and sovereigntist), they have virtually no policy room to argue for their continued existence.
The first crisis this party faces in the aftermath of their historic annihilation is their utter rudderlessness.
2. Loss of Official Party Status
In the Canadian Parliament, a party must win 12 seats in order to be officially recognized. With just four seats, the Bloc now falls short of this standard. It is a heavy blow for their party; without it, they do not have the right to participate in the House during Question Period, nor do they have access to funding for staff and research afforded only to officially recognized parties. This development will starve them of attention through QP and greatly limit their ability to efficiently gather resources to conduct House business. In short, they can't do much in the House of Commons as elected MPs.
3. Political Contributions Will Plummet
As a result of becoming a non-factor in the House, there is little incentive for Quebec business or individuals to contribute financially to the BQ's upkeep. They cannot claim to represent the province's interests in the House anymore -- not when the NDP owns more seats in Quebec than they ever did in their two decades of existence. All that money will divert from the Bloc and start to flow into NDP coffers, which should give them to opportunity to marshal resources into the province on a scale they could never reach previously. Since the NDP will want to be in Quebec for the long term, it's logical they will invest significant capital into building an efficient electoral machine in the province.
The research money the NDP will get is about to get a generous bump upwards as well, since such funding is doled out proportionally based on the size of a party's caucus. When the guys replacing you will have three times as much cash as they did before to do what you used to do, the writing's on the wall. And if you can't get your friends to give you the cash you need to fight back, the battle is a hopeless cause.
4. And the Coup de GrĂ¢ce ...
Stephen Harper declared last night that his government would get back to work today. There are a number of items on his to-do list in the first 100 days, most notably his commitments to pass his budget and re-introduce his crime agenda in the Commons. But also high among his priorities is his determination to end per vote public subsidies for political parties.
The Conservatives have argued these subsidies artificially prop up the BQ and remove any urgency from its external fundraising efforts. So the removal of the subsidies will starve them of financing critical to any attempt at rebuilding the party.
In 2010, the Bloc raised $834,762 in direct donations from individuals, but collected $2.8 million in per vote subsidies.
I've already said their donation base is about to shrink dramatically.
You do the math.
Bloc Leader Gilles Duceppe went down to defeat in his riding, along with nearly everyone else in his caucus. The disastrous BQ campaign can be attributed to a lack of energy, purpose and cohesion, and the person who has to take the lion's share of the blame is Duceppe. There was no way he could have remained as leader, even if he'd pulled out a win in his seat. The first Bloc MP ever elected to the House of Commons is done.
But the bigger reason why the BQ's future is so hampered by his loss is due to a lack of a clear successor. Duceppe has taken up so much of the party's oxygen over the years that there is no heir apparent to his deeply corroded crown. Plus, with the repudiation coming from all sides of their traditional support base (both nationalist and sovereigntist), they have virtually no policy room to argue for their continued existence.
The first crisis this party faces in the aftermath of their historic annihilation is their utter rudderlessness.
2. Loss of Official Party Status
In the Canadian Parliament, a party must win 12 seats in order to be officially recognized. With just four seats, the Bloc now falls short of this standard. It is a heavy blow for their party; without it, they do not have the right to participate in the House during Question Period, nor do they have access to funding for staff and research afforded only to officially recognized parties. This development will starve them of attention through QP and greatly limit their ability to efficiently gather resources to conduct House business. In short, they can't do much in the House of Commons as elected MPs.
3. Political Contributions Will Plummet
As a result of becoming a non-factor in the House, there is little incentive for Quebec business or individuals to contribute financially to the BQ's upkeep. They cannot claim to represent the province's interests in the House anymore -- not when the NDP owns more seats in Quebec than they ever did in their two decades of existence. All that money will divert from the Bloc and start to flow into NDP coffers, which should give them to opportunity to marshal resources into the province on a scale they could never reach previously. Since the NDP will want to be in Quebec for the long term, it's logical they will invest significant capital into building an efficient electoral machine in the province.
The research money the NDP will get is about to get a generous bump upwards as well, since such funding is doled out proportionally based on the size of a party's caucus. When the guys replacing you will have three times as much cash as they did before to do what you used to do, the writing's on the wall. And if you can't get your friends to give you the cash you need to fight back, the battle is a hopeless cause.
4. And the Coup de GrĂ¢ce ...
Stephen Harper declared last night that his government would get back to work today. There are a number of items on his to-do list in the first 100 days, most notably his commitments to pass his budget and re-introduce his crime agenda in the Commons. But also high among his priorities is his determination to end per vote public subsidies for political parties.
The Conservatives have argued these subsidies artificially prop up the BQ and remove any urgency from its external fundraising efforts. So the removal of the subsidies will starve them of financing critical to any attempt at rebuilding the party.
In 2010, the Bloc raised $834,762 in direct donations from individuals, but collected $2.8 million in per vote subsidies.
I've already said their donation base is about to shrink dramatically.
You do the math.
A Quick Comment on Election 2011
As the votes continue to be counted, the seat count at this exact moment is 166 Conservatives, 103 NDP, 34 Liberals, 4 Bloc Quebecois and 1 Green Party MP.
It is a truly amazing result. The Canadian electoral map has been completely redone. This election is a watershed moment in our political history.
I will have more analysis after the results are more solid. But let me signal one thing that I will be exploring in the days ahead -- the assumption that there is a left-wing split in this country between Liberals and the NDP. John Ibbitson wrote a response article about the election results, arguing this point. He wrote that now is the time to combine the parties, and merge Canada's two left-of-centre parties.
This is wrong. The Liberals are NOT a left-of-centre party. But if they want to be taken over by the NDP, they should feel free to propose it.
Now is not the time for Jack Layton to even entertain such a proposal. Most progressives reject outright that the Liberals can be counted among their ranks. We will see what the Liberals do next, and how long Ignatieff will remain at the helm, but an NDP/Liberal merger can only happen on NDP terms at this point, which is exactly why the Liberals will never do it.
Let's give Layton and his team the next four years to strengthen themselves as a true government-in-waiting and then see what voters think. The people of Canada are sick of the pundits and the Liberals telling them what they should think.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)