Tuesday, April 05, 2011

Afghan Detainees & The Principle of Public Accountability

In the Globe and Mail this morning, columnist Lawrence Martin reminds us of the difficulties Stephen Harper and the Tories may face if the Afghan detainee issue rears its head in the coming weeks. 

As Martin writes: "The issue, we recall, turns on whether Canadian officials knowingly handed over prisoners for torture by Afghan authorities, a potential violation of the Geneva Conventions. Mr. Harper’s government steadfastly refused to provide documents on the matter, but were ordered to do so a year ago by Speaker Peter Milliken. A special committee was then appointed to make sure any released materials wouldn’t compromise national security."

This committee is nearly ready to do a document dump. The Bloc Quebecois, before the government fell in the House of Commons, forced a resolution requiring the special committee to come back with information for public consumption by April 15. In addition, the Military Police Complaints Commission is preparing a report on the matter. Both processes are moving along, and it is possible both releases could take place before voting day on May 2.

Unsurprisingly, the Tories will do just about anything to prevent this information from seeing the light of day. They have gone to court to limit the scope of the Commission report, and Liberals suspect the Tories will file a motion in court to delay release of documents from the parliamentary committee. If successful, they will have neutered the issue that, I feel, is the one that will finally set the Tories firmly on defence on their bread-and-butter issue - accountability. This government has become skilled at not being accountable while preaching it at every stop. If you're a criminal, you need to face the music. If you're in a political party, raise your own money and stop looking for a public subsidy.

But if you're the government, shouldn't you answer to Parliament? Shouldn't you listen to the opinions of the parliamentary officers you appointed to monitor federal budgets, the lobbyists on Parliament Hill, integrity in the House, and to audit federal financial statements? The list of actions over the past five years by members of the government against a myriad of officials to obscure the truth, distort facts, mislead the public, keep Parliament in the dark, cover up misdeeds and hypocritically reward friends is breathtaking.

Only the Afghan detainee issue, which also brings up the second prorogation of Parliament (the one that led to open public protests against Harper's anti-democratic behaviour) has the potential to stick Tory feet firmly in the cynical fire they've stoked for five years. If either of these public airings of dirty laundry take place (especially if it happens before the English debate), I would hope that Canadians would finally sit up and pay attention to the abuses of this government.

After all, this is the government that originally pledged to be different than the Liberals back in the 2005-06 campaign. Why have you not held them to their word, Canada? And because we collectively haven't done it, what does that say about us? Why do Conservatives get a free pass on violating the Geneva Conventions and then covering it up for years, while the Liberals paid for the sponsorship scandal?

I don't vote Grit or Tory as a rule, so I'm no fan of the Liberals either. But fair is fair, people. The time has come to punish the Tories for treating us like unprincipled naïve fools. I hope my fellow Canadians will finally see the light.

Saturday, April 02, 2011

Whither Quebec, Mr. Harper?

At the end of a very weird first week of the election campaign, a few cracks are showing in the Conservative juggernaut. When the election writs were dropped, the general consensus was that the Liberals were way behind, and were perhaps a little deluded for pushing for the fall of the Harper government in the first place. After all, the leader was seen as being something of a dud, the Tories were edging towards majority government territory in the polls, the NDP were polling fairly well and the party internally was cash poor and in organizational disarray.

Well, so much for that theory. Since Harper made two crucial decisions in the opening week, the Liberals have already started to pick up some ground. The first was the Harper-initiated call for a head-to-head debate with Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff. Perhaps Harper hasn't been paying attention, but Iggy's been feeling sprightly and feisty so far. He picked up the insinuation right away and goaded Harper, daring him to actually agree to the fight. Harper bailed out faster than the US government sank cash into its financial sector. The misstep made the Prime Minister look silly, and emboldened the Liberals. Score one for the Grits.

The other decision deals with Newfoundland, which I'll deal with in a moment. But there is a third factor that has now come into play, and this is Harper's insistence on talking up the "dangerous coalition" that will take over the country if he doesn't win a majority.

First of all, minority governments rule by coalition decision-making, by design. Nothing got passed in the last Parliament unless one of the opposition parties in the House of Commons supported the government on a vote. So vote by vote, informal coalitions were formed to ensure the work of the House resulted in legislation being approved. No, the coalition is not formal. But Canadians wanted to see the parties work together, by consensus, and come up with policies that reflect the compromise our nation is famous for abroad. But no, the Tories don't want compromise - it's not in their DNA. They'd rather rule by fiat. And so that's why the government eventually antagonized the House to the point of losing power on a vote that found them in contempt of Parliament.

(By the way, don't listen to any Tory who says the government fell on its budget. That is a bald-faced, 100%, backed-up-by-the-facts lie. There never was a vote on that budget, and anyone who insinuates otherwise cannot be trusted to tell the truth about anything else in this election.)

So now, Newfoundland. Harper went with a cheque in his hand to St. John's to tell the good people on the Rock that the feds would guarantee "a loan to finance $4.2 -billion of the $6.2-billion [Lower Churchill] project to run an underwater power line from Newfoundland to New England." The Tories did this in order to curry favour with voters on the island, who shut the party out in the 2008 election when then-NL Premier Danny Williams campaigned against them due to a squabble over equalization payments. This time, the Tories need those seats in pursuit of their elusive majority government.

Then Quebec started squawking. Premier Jean Charest condemned the promise, arguing the federal government has never intervened in the power market and should refrain from doing so in this case (lest it damage the profitability and prospects of Hydro-Quebec). All the parties in Quebec City united behind the premier, and Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe also fell in line. The united front from the nationalists and federalists in the province prompted Harper to promise resolution of an outstanding issue with Quebec over a financial settlement on the HST. The deal, which Quebec claims will cost the federal government $2.2 billion, has been unsuccessfully negotiated for the past 14 months, with no resolution possible until after the election ends.

Basically, the Tories are trying to buy off Newfoundlanders with the loan guarantee for Lower Churchill, and then decided they'd better try to buy off Quebeckers by extending the HST olive branch (though that issue was going to be decided eventually anyway).

Never mind that the Tories had the chance to set the money aside for the Quebec HST deal when they tabled their budget a couple weeks ago. This is an election, dammit, and they have to win!

Never mind that if they'd included the money in the budget, there's a chance the Bloc would have supported the document, and there wouldn't be an election going on right now at all.

Never mind that the Lower Churchill deal is being done in such a way to infuriate Quebec, which built its enviable infrastructure to transport energy to other jurisdictions without a cent of federal cash.

There's an election to be won, dammit!

None of this looks good for the Tories. It's only the end of the first week and already they're starting to look desperate outside their core constituency in Saskatchewan and Alberta. While the Newfoundland deal reaffirmed its commitment to the principles its base embraces, how is the hasty promise to Quebec to settle the HST issue playing in Calgary? As Harper tries to balance competing interests in different parts of the country while projecting an image of competent benevolent demagoguery, the chicken coop is slowly filling up.

As I said to friends before the campaign started, I never viewed Election 2011 as a slam dunk for Harper. I think the Tories are starting to realize they are in a real battle, and that perhaps they underestimated the competition. They are trying to stage manage a majority government, but the stage was never set the way they'd imagined it before the campaign started. They have looked static and reactionary, while the Liberals have been more flexible, more open, and far more united than first advertised.

The NDP is perceived to be struggling thus far, a situation that (on its face) benefits the Liberal Party. The more Jack Layton is sidelined, the greater the chance left-of-centre voters will hold their nose and vote Grit to stop Harper's drive for a majority. But this reality is fraught with danger for the opposition, for the NDP is better positioned in some places (such as parts of Atlantic Canada and in Saskatchewan) to defeat the Tories than the Liberals are. A collapse of NDP support on the prairies may make the majority Harper seeks more attainable.

All of this points to a campaign that is only now starting to capture the imaginations of Canadians. Over the next few weeks the seeds of trends that are trying to emerge now will shake themselves out. Not all of them point to a strong Tory government. The people running Harper's campaign should be very wary heading into Week 2. There are nascent signs that the electorate is more restless than they've banked on, with the possibility of a reduced minority becoming more real by the day, unless they respond. Are they paying attention? Are they listening? Can they sense the rumblings and react appropriately?

Sit back and watch. We're about to find out.

Friday, March 25, 2011

The Coalition: Tory Manna from Heaven

So it's on. 

Prime Minister Stephen Harper has historically been found in contempt of Parliament, and the House of Commons voted no confidence in his government by a margin of 156 to 145. This outcome will plunge the country into a campaign to elect the 41st Parliament in a vote most likely to take place on May 2. Harper will formally meet with Governor-General David Johnston in the morning to request the dissolution of Parliament, the election writ will be dropped, and away we will go.

“We are the people’s representatives. When the government spends money, the people have a right to know what it is to be spent on. Parliament does not issue blank cheques.”
- Opposition Leader Michael Ignatieff


“We find ourselves here today faced with the most partisan of attacks from an opposition coalition bent on defeating this government at all costs.”
- Government House Leader John Baird


The contempt finding comes from the Harper government not thinking it necessary to bother to inform MPs how much they intend to spend on their jet fighters and jail plans. Not unreasonably, the House of Commons requested the full and accurate accounting of those expenses be tabled. The government did not comply. Hence, the government is no more. There will be a lot of propaganda from the Tories about this election being "unnecessary" because stability in the economy is paramount in Conservative minds. Never mind that economists think that's hogwash, they will keep spitting that line in the hope it sticks.

They also hope the line about the Liberals wanting a "coalition" to stick as well. The ham-handed handling of the Coalition Crisis by all parties helped to transform the c-word into a dirty utterance, a development the Tories are enlisting with gusto in their attempt to remain in power. Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff keeps dodging it, saying the clear choice is to vote either for a change of government by voting Liberal or for more of the same contemptuous crap by voting for anyone else. Nice try, Iggy.

Though today's answer was better than the "red door, blue door" Matrix reference of yesterday, it won't make the questions go away. As Andrew Coyne wrote in his article, the Grits better come up with a plausible response, and quickly. The Tories threaten to hijack the entire debate by repeating the word "coalition" ad naseum. If they are permitted to do that, then attacking the Tories on the economy and their ethics becomes a moot point.

Because make no mistake, the Tories are also vulnerable on the economic file. When they came to power in early 2006, the Martin Liberals were in surplus with adequate cash flows to deal with unexpected eventualities. The Tories immediately set about eliminating our government's fiscal cushion through a number of measures, most famously cutting the GST to 5% in a move most economists argued made no fiscal sense. When the country was heading for recession, the Tories pretended to party like it was still 1999. Then when stimulus spending became a financial necessity, Ottawa ended up deeper in deficit than we would have had they maintained the fiscal prudence of the previous Liberal government. The current Finance Minister, Jim Flaherty, has presided over the most profligate period of federal spending in our history. The Tories have expanded the federal public service, eliminated contingencies for future financial shocks and doled out boutique tax breaks that further strain federal coffers. Yet they are the default "best stewards of the national economy?" Someone needs to take them to task, because their record screams otherwise.

I'm no fan of the Liberal Party of Canada, but why is it that Tories, who entered elections in 1993 and 2011 with historic deficits, are considered better financial stewards than the Liberals, who left the country's books in a surplus position? It continues to defy logic.

And since the government has fallen on issues of transparency, ethics and clean government, it will be easy for the other parties to put these questions to the public during the campaign. How can you re-elect a government that continues to so blatantly disrespect you, that believes they can do anything in your name and you'll take it, they will ask the public. How can you re-elect a government that won't tell you how much their planned military and correctional expenditures will cost, yet claim they can balance the nation's books by 2015, they will ask taxpayers. How can you re-elect a government that got elected in the first place by promising open and accountable government, while at the same time orchestrating a huge electoral fraud, they will ask voters.

How indeed?

Well, they can if they think a coalition of bumbling fools will replace the current batch of corrupt, contemptuous fools.

Mr. Ignatieff, for the love of all that's good and holy, answer the bloody question so we can get on with the real issues of the election. Please!

Wednesday, March 09, 2011

What is the True Cost of Government?

It now appears the opposition may be maneuvering to bring down the "Harper Government" on ethics before the federal budget is introduced in the House of Commons on March 22. The triple-bill of: allegations of improper conduct against Immigration Minister Jason Kenney, the ongoing issues surrounding Bev Oda and her handling of the CIDA Kairos affair, and the charges from Elections Canada in the "in-and-out" scheme the Conservative national campaign conducted during the 2006 campaign have made the Tories vulnerable on one of their major bread and butter issues.

The opposition smells blood and the Harperites are in full damage control mode. If the Liberals, NDP and Bloc are looking at the political landscape, they must be thinking this might be their last, best chance to take down the Tories.

For some weird reason, the Conservatives have the economy issue locked up (despite running the country into a record deficit situation, which may not have been necessary had they not chopped corporate taxes and the GST at the exact moment we went into a recession they denied was on the horizon, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary). Taking the government down on a budget vote would necessarily make the election about the budget, and the opposition has had little luck standing toe-to-toe with Harper on policy.  They've landed a few body blows that hurt a bit, but nothing that would take out the champ.

The issue of ethics is different, though. The Tories claimed the mantle of accountability and transparency when they beat Paul Martin in 2006. Five years later, the Liberals (even with the sponsorship scandal) look no better or worse than these guys on ethics. If the government is vulnerable to having anything stick to them, it's anything that calls their integrity into question.

Worse for them, should there be continuing negative publicity from the court case associated with the in and out scandal, it will likely come out during the campaign. The sight of Tories walking into a courthouse to face charges they made illegal claims to get money from taxpayers in excess of campaign spending limits must be too juicy for the opposition parties to easily dismiss.

What I want the opposition to do, though, is link the economy and the ethics issues together by asking a basic question - even if you, Everyday Canadian, accept that the Tories are the best stewards of the economy, what is the cost to democracy to continue Conservative rule? At what cost to our morals, values and ethics do we re-elect Harper and Co. to office?

Line up all the questionable activities, the arrogant dismissals of criticism (and critics), the ministerial indiscretions, the prorogations and the like, and have a tally sheet that looks like a financial spreadsheet. Attack the Tories on their financial record (which, despite John Ibbitson's musings, isn't all that great) and graphically increase the fiscal deficit shown to Canadians when you add in the democratic deficit. 

Make the case that Canada is poorer today than it was five years ago, but not in ways Canadians had expected. Remind Canadians again and again they elected the Tories to clean up government, not to make it MORE secretive, MORE control-obsessed or MORE corrupt than the Liberals. And yet on the issue of ethics, what have the Tories done for us lately?

The biggest problem, of course, is the party best situated to try and topple the Tories are the very Liberals who gave us the sponsorship scandal. Have five years in the electoral wilderness been enough to purge that party of its worst instincts? Perhaps, perhaps not. That's for the electorate to decide. 

But there probably will be no other glorious moments of weakness for the Tories after this one. They are bloodied by this issue, not floored, and are still quite capable of staging an effective counter-offensive. Plus, they start with the advantage in the poll numbers that gives many Liberals pause. 

But I think honestly that this is as good as it's going to get. Find your moment, put forward the non-confidence motion of your choosing, and force the issue, Liberal Party of Canada. Fail to do so now, and we'll be talking about a Harper majority in six months.

Friday, March 04, 2011

In and Out ... of Office?

I swear to every thinking person who reads this blog -- the "in and out" scheme the federal Tories used for its national advertising during the 2006 election campaign is going to be the undoing of the Harper government.

They are pretending not to take the risk very seriously in public specifically because the issue is potentially fatal to their cause. The recent appellate court defeat on their civil suit takes away their crowing point about the courts being on their side.  And the charges laid against four party members (including two sitting Senators) puts a lie to this being an insignificant "administrative dispute."

Now, let me be clear -- as other bloggers and writers have already posted on the internet, this issue is not always the simplest to explain to people, is it the kind of thing cynical voters would not be shocked to hear about, given that it's politicians involved in this scandal, and it is likely to be forgotten in the heat of an election campaign. It's not likely this issue in isolation will bring down the government.

The reason this one will sting is because it's a definitive straw on the pile already perched on Canadians' collective camel-like back.

This is a party that campaigned in 2006 on being the party of accountability and transparency. How can they ever make that claim again if Elections Canada proves its charges in court? I mean, these charges stem from how they conducted themselves in the campaign that originally brought them to power. That would be the same election campaign when the Tories were beating the Liberals over the head with their copy of the Gomery inquiry report on the sponsorship scandal. They were going to change the culture of government, they said, and make sure this kind of thing could never happen again.

All while acting illegally in their own campaign advertising campaign. The hypocrisy and irony run thick and rich.

The Tories have collected a small stack of ethics-defying mini brouhahas over the course the past five years. They have created an almost militaristic environment for government MPs and Senators who are expected to toe the line or find another place of employment. The Prime Minister's Office could have taught Trudeau, Mulroney and Chrétien a thing or two about how to be top dog -- the centralized control of the government by the current PMO is unparalleled in Canadian history.  

The scandalous Afghan detainee imbroglio that led to a prorogation of Parliament feeds into the party's reputation as serial skirters of ultimate political responsibility. The earlier prorogation during the Coalition Crisis was another example of Harper's obsessive need for control and his party's willingness to do whatever is necessary to retain power, no matter the cost to our sense of fairness and our faith in democratic principles. The uproar over Bev Oda's handling of CIDA's Kairos funding decision is another instance where Tory pre-government rhetoric and the five-years-of-Tory-government reality don't line up. The examples of Conservative misconduct, arrogance and outright disdain for Parliament and other key institutions are numerous.

Add it all up, and it becomes obvious that taking a strong line of attack by lining all these examples up could be a powerful argument for opposition to Harper's government to make in any upcoming election campaign.

Will it happen? Her Majesty's Loyal Opposition will have its moment sometime relatively soon. But given the current plight of the Liberal party, it's tough to see them pulling it together enough to do the necessary damage. A physically weakened Jack Layton may not be the best messenger on the hustings if the electoral writ is dropped this year. And Gilles Duceppe will do what he always does -- win a majority of Quebec seats while having a minimal impact on the cross-Canada debate.

But if the Liberals and NDP can sharpen their knives just enough to inflict enough damage from both sides, it might be enough to deny a renewed mandate for the Tories. Sadly, the knives in opposition will be used mostly to try and take out each other for short-term advantage amongst the votes they already collectively command.

I wish I was optimistic that they can remove Harper from government. I'm not. But this agglomeration of greasy, sticky, grimy, slimy dealings from the Tories means any renewed mandate they earn in the future will be weighed down by the malfeasance clogging their engine of government. Moving ahead with a believable air of confidence and integrity will be extremely difficult to muster.

So will the in and out scandal undo Harper? Yes, sooner or later. But maybe not in 2011.