Thursday, April 28, 2011

The Mercer Effect

"If you look at these numbers, that would represent potentially a pretty interesting shift in the balance of power, certainly on the opposition benches. That balance of power is kind of in the hands of the youth vote right now."
- Jaideep Mukerji, vice-president of Angus Reid Public Opinion, commenting yesterday on April 26 polling results

Rick Mercer's now-famous rant challenging young people aged 18 to 24 to vote has had a shocking effect on this campaign. To the surprise of many, youth have mobilized through creating new groups focused on getting out the youth vote, utilizing social media and other means to push their message, and through the vote mob phenomenon sweeping across Canada's university campuses. Despite condescending criticism from "wise elders" who dismiss it all as just so much noise, the focused sharpness of the retorts to such talk, plus the massive shifts in recent polls, indicate Canada's youth are finally seeking to be heard en masse through increased political engagement.

We must wait until the votes are counted to see how many youth actually turn out to cast ballots, but the early indications are that the Conservatives should be concerned. Last year, fewer than 1 in 5 youth expressed support for Harper, and there's little reason to believe that's changed very much. So any significant increase in youth voter turnout is not going to fall into their column. However, it's tough to say how that will influence vote splits in competitive ridings given how unpredictable the campaign has become in last week.

One thing is certain, though -- something is afoot in the electorate, and unpredictable things will almost assuredly happen. Will Jack Layton become Leader of the Opposition? Will Stephen Harper succeed in winning a majority with a reduced percentage of the national vote from 2008? Will Michael Ignatieff still be the Liberal leader by Canada Day? Will Gilles Duceppe still be the Bloc leader by Victoria Day? And just how many young people will vote next Monday anyway?

Right now, as Mukerji posited yesterday, a sizeable factor in how the vote turns out is in the hands of Canada's youth. If they seize it, our politics will be forever altered.

Source:
http://anomalism.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d1ps0d
“It’s conventional wisdom of all political parties that young people will not vote. And the parties, they like it that way … so please, if you are between 18 and 25 and you want to scare the heck out of the people who run this country, this time around, do the unexpected. Take twenty minutes out of your day and do what young people all over the world are dying to do: vote.”
- Rick Mercer

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

The Rae Effect

Alright already. I've come to have enough of this foolishness.

Bob Rae was elected premier before most kids in university and college today were even born. While many of us remember his time at the head of Ontario's only NDP government, a sizeable portion do not.

The spectre of NDP government at the national level has nothing to do with the dearly departed Rae government when it comes to voters under the age of 35. It's just not their issue. It's been nearly 21 years since that government was elected. Older people need to wake up and stop talking about it like there's some ugly NDP gremlins hiding behind a door someplace, ready to blow up the Canadian economy.

The NDP has governed provincially in Nova Scotia, Manitoba, Saskatchewan and B.C. as well. Those provinces are doing just fine. The party had the poor timing of being elected in my home province during a very serious economic downturn that no government survived unscathed. The recession of the early 1990s led to some of the most searing pain ever experienced in Canada from a fiscal perspective -- a difficult economic time that resulted in the rebalancing of our collective priorities and a shift in our political thinking.

Running massive deficits became taboo. Competent fiscal management became the norm. And that happened for all parties across the spectrum, including the NDP.

To be as blunt as possible: the NDP in the provinces, as well as Canada's NDP, know that massive deficit financing will lead to electoral ruin, so they won't do it.

Ultimately, spending is all about priorities. The Harper Tories are the most spend-happy government in Canadian history, and managed to turn a healthy surplus into a massive deficit in less than five years. How? They made stupid tax cuts (GST), economically dubious tax cuts (corporate, specialized "boutique" credits), and significant spending increases (military, public services) all at the same time. Even a Dipper can do that math.

So I don't want to hear anything more about the NDP being irresponsible with the federal purse. While people speculate on what Dippers might do to tax and spend us into oblivion, the Tories are actually and actively undertaxing and spending us into oblivion.

Enough already about the bloody Rae government. Let's focus on the one we've got right now, and hold them to account. 

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

The Layton Effect

Leave it to the good people of Quebec to figure out how to break the logjam our federal politics had become.

The scene: A Stephen Harper led minority government many didn't elect and don't want to support remains in power largely on the strength of voters on the Prairies (who are statistically over-represented in Parliament), concentrated pockets of support around Vancouver, Quebec City and southern Ontario, and smatterings of seats in the Atlantic. The challengers, limited to traditional support bases in various urban centres across the country (Liberals and NDP) and suburban and rural Quebec (the Bloc) could not rally enough supporters and/or credibility to topple an increasingly arrogant and imperious Prime Minister.

The actors: When the writs were dropped, Gilles Duceppe led the Bloc into one more election (perhaps one too many?) in a province where the Liberals can't gain any traction due to past scandals, the Tories are limited by a left-leaning electorate and the NDP have typically been a non-factor. Most voters in the rest of the country expected more of the same -- an election about nothing, one that would lead to a similar Parliament to the one that was just dissolved.

But something funny happened on the way to history repeating itself. Humans intervened. 

I had been saying to friends before the campaign started that this one felt different. I believed something was going to change this time around. I didn't think it would be a massive late-campaign surge in NDP support, though. I was just as blindsided by that as anyone. But when you stop and think about it, it makes a lot of sense.

Irrespective of your own politics, try to think like a Quebecker for a moment:

The Harper government, by and large, doesn't represent you, or what you believe in. Quebec is filled with people who lean further left than most other Canadians, and have a stronger belief in the welfare state. The Prime Minister just isn't your kind of people, and you're baffled at how he manages to garner the levels of support he does in the rest of Canada. You'd love to see the Conservatives get tossed out, but your countrymen and women elsewhere in the country simply aren't getting it, in your view.

The Bloc Quebecois just celebrated 20 years of existence. Besides some small policy victories with minority governments under Paul Martin and then Harper, what the hell have they done, really? Out of desperation, they're now chirping about this election being a contrast between sovereigntists and federalists, and want you to believe a vote for them is the best way to represent Quebec federally. But the Bloc will never govern -- not as the lead party in government nor as a junior partner in a minority or coalition situation either. You feel the Prime Minister on one point -- the province needs a voice in government. But you know that voice will never be Duceppe's. Plus, you want to turn the referendum page and get on with your life. The constitutional debate is soooo 1995.

After the Gomery inquiry into the sponsorship scandal, the Liberal brand is mud in your province. Michael Ignatieff is clearly not one of your own, and has done little to change your opinion of the Liberal Party. He hasn't been effective at promoting his platform, articulating a new vision for the country or at eviscerating the competition. Nothing he's done leads you to believe he's a strong leader, and his party acts as if they are entitled to a renewed shot at government. Maybe they need to sit it out one last time before they fully comprehend the message their 2006 defeat should have taught them.

That leaves the NDP. Their leader, Jack Layton, was born and raised in your province and sounds like you (at least the anglo you). His politics line up with yours better than any other party not named the Bloc. He's been working at getting around, getting to know your issues, and he's done a decent job at it. He's easily the most personable and positive of the federal leaders, plus he has an everyman charm you find endearing. He speaks your language, both literally and figuratively. In short, he's a leader you dig. Why not give him a chance?

Hence, having successfully made the case that Quebeckers do have a choice, the NDP's support in the province has skyrocketed. So much so, there's the real possibility they can win some seats in the province, and potentially elsewhere as well. If current trends hold, I figure the NDP should come out of the election with at least 10 Quebec seats, and more if Quebeckers cotton onto the idea of shifting their votes to a party recent polls suggest could be the Official Opposition with their support.

It puts the lie to Duceppe's claim that Quebec's voice can be best expressed by the Bloc, a party that has no chance of being the Official Opposition after May 2. It also has one other potential unintended consequence that, once people in the province think it over, might appeal to them:

Vote NDP in massive numbers, and Quebec might be the dominant province in an NDP-led government.

That's right. I said it.

If Quebeckers can read pollsters' seat projections (and they can), they may come to realize the Tories cannot govern if the NDP and Liberal caucuses combined form a majority in the House of Commons. Under the seat distribution scenario laid out by yesterday's EKOS survey, Harper's government could fall on its Throne Speech (or on its budget shortly thereafter), and the Governor General would most likely ask Layton to form a government. The Liberals, preoccupied with agonizing over whether or not to dump Ignatieff as their leader, would be in no position to object. The Bloc, reduced to parliamentary irrelevance, would be thrown into existential crisis. The NDP would then be handed its historic moment -- to govern the country in a minority situation, most likely propped up by the Liberals.

There's even the possibility of a formal agreement between the NDP and the Liberals, similar to the accord reached between the two parties at the provincial level in Ontario between 1987 and 1990.

Can the NDP hold onto its unprecedented status at this late stage in the electoral game? We shall have to watch over the next six days to find out. But one thing is certain -- if NDP is able to muscle the Bloc into a severely weakened state and become the largest federal party in Quebec, and then form the Official Opposition or a minority government in Ottawa, the national political dynamic will be forever changed.

All those people who mocked Layton earlier in the campaign for refusing to drop talk about becoming Prime Minister have been given their comeuppance. What once seemed unimaginable is now inching closer to the NDP Leader's grasp.

Hang on, Canada. This is getting really interesting.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

David Johnston is a Smart Guy

I read Blake Batson's blog post about the choice facing Canadians voters on May 2: according to him, we must choose between a Harper majority or a coalition government. Hogwash. I encourage Mr. Batson to read my post from yesterday to figure out why the Liberals and NDP may in the end choose to permit the Tories to govern.

But in the event the government did fall shortly after introducing its Throne Speech or budget, the Official Opposition (probably the Liberals) would clearly have the right to seek the confidence of the House to govern the country, if invited to try by the Governor General.

Note I said if invited to try by the Governor General. Harper, bless his soul, chose David Johnston to replace Michaelle Jean in the vice-regal post so he could deal with just such a scenario. A constitutional expert, our head of state knows full well that it's Parliament who determines who becomes Prime Minister, and not the electorate. So does Harper. If Johnston says, "yo, Iggy, you wanna give this thing a shot?" why should the Liberals say no? And Jack Layton is right to observe that if a Tory minority government fell quickly “we shouldn't immediately go back to an election; that would be ridiculous.” The Governor General knows that too.

But under no circumstance I can see would the Liberals find it advantageous to invite the NDP into a coalition government. Why validate a party that's a major thorn in your side, currently bleeding some of your support in Quebec, making your life a living hell on the prairies and complicating things in B.C. (if mid-campaign polls are to be believed)? If any of these trends hold up on Election Day, why give the NDP a taste of power now, at the moment the Liberals will most need to bury them? It makes no strategic sense.

Canadians are smart. They can smell the manure pile Harper's shovelling from a long way off. As Douglas Bell wrote in the Globe and Mail this morning, the coalition dog won't hunt.

We have three choices -- believe Harper's ridiculousness, vote our consciences, or try to play the strategic voting game. Good luck with that, Canada. But Jack won't be in Cabinet by July. Ain't gonna happen.

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

A Minority Report on Stephen Harper

Today, John Ibbitson wrote on his blog about Stephen Harper's future after the next election. While trying to convince Canadians that his government will surely be replaced by a "reckless coalition" if the Tories win anything less than a majority mandate, history, parliamentary precedent and common sense argue otherwise.

Harper wants us to believe that Michael Ignatieff will lead a creaky minority propped up by the NDP and the Bloc should the Conservatives win less than the 155 seats needed for a majority. This presupposes that shortly after the election, the Tories will be unable to command the confidence of the full House of Commons (expressed through votes on the Speech from the Throne that always begins a new parliamentary session, or on the budget that would have be presented shortly thereafter if they survive the Throne Speech vote).

If the Tories were defeated in such a scenario, the Governor General would have the option of asking the Leader of the Opposition to form a government and to attempt to secure the confidence of the House, rather than call another election. Since Iggy is most likely to be Opposition Leader at that time, this line of thinking then elevates the Liberal Leader to the Prime Minister's chair, and the red and blue ties and scarves would switch sides of the aisle on Parliament Hill.

There is a real possibility this could happen. I don't discount this as a true, potentially persuasive option for the Opposition under our system. However, it is not at all clear this would actually happen right away.

A third Tory minority led by Stephen Harper may be unappetizing to the Liberals and NDP, but it may be even more unappealing to the Tories. If the opposition permits the Conservative Party to continue governing, Tory party insiders might become bolder and more vocal in their dissatisfaction with Harper's leadership. Some minds may reach the conclusion that the key to a majority victory is in the pocket of another politician -- one the voters haven't made solid conclusions about and may make it possible to wipe the slate clean in time for another kick at the can. Tories may very well realize Stephen Harper threw two hard punches at Liberal leaders they perceived as weak (Stephane Dion and Ignatieff), but still couldn't knock them out for good. By then, Harper will be batting oh-for-four in pursuit of a majority government, a stat line any grade school softball player can tell you isn't particularly good. Allowing discontent to bubble on government benches may be more palatable to opposition parties who will need to fundraise and consolidate after May 2 in preparation for the next election than seizing the reins of government themselves.

Also, potentially epic bad news is on the horizon for a re-elected Tory minority. The issues to be brought forward in the Auditor-General's G8 report and the various documents and reports set to be released on Afghan detainees whenever Parliament reconvenes will apply the match to the kerosene-soaked ethics of the government. Standing back and watching the straw man atop the Tories' high horse set ablaze may be a sight too irresistible to Opposition eyes to miss seeing, especially the Liberals. To have Harper hoisted on his own petard over abusive spending, blatant pork-barrelling, cover-ups and double dealing under the glaring light of public parliamentary scrutiny is something no Opposition party could ever do more effectively on the campaign trail or from government benches. There is also the real possibility Harper could lose a minister or two (hello, Tony Clement!) over these missteps as well. There is a chance for a longer term victory for the Liberals that comes from the short-term compromise of leaving Harper at 24 Sussex.

Keeping the Tories in power could also fit the NDP narrative. Jack Layton (if current polling trends hold up) may emerge stronger from a campaign he was expected to be more damaged by than any other opposition leader. Using this strength to demand concessions from a Tory minority government may demonstrate to the voters his ongoing commitment to making Parliament work, and expose the Prime Minister to more charges of autocratic, anti-democratic behaviour if the offer is refused or ignored. If the PM does this, he risks coming off looking like the bully the Opposition said he was all along during the recently-completed campaign; if Harper listens, it may make him look good but it would also increase Layton's credibility. Either way, the NDP could paint the Tories into a corner: either play ball and compromise, or get booted from office as a direct result of publicly exposed non-cooperation. For Tories to keep claiming to be a party interested in moderate, responsive government while refusing to engage with willing opposition MPs in Parliament would be an exercise in blatant hypocrisy.

Under such circumstances, the pressures on Harper would build. Unable to push an agenda exclusively to Tory tastes, and with no clear path to a majority government under his leadership, it is hard to see how the Conservatives could stomach leaving Harper at the helm for an extended period. And if the scandals of the past five years (swept under the rug before the election call in the hope a majority could be secured before the truth came out) are systematically exposed, a Harper resignation could come sooner rather than later.

The Conservative Leader knows this. He won't talk about it, because that outcome scares the daylights out of him. Being forced into another minority mandate takes many of the tools he wishes to use after May 2 out of his hands. The control he covets would be nearly impossible to get back. Instead of steering the boat, he'd be forced to grab the wheel and hold on for dear life.

Given some of the other possible outcomes available to the opposition parties, that's a storm they may be willing ride out.